Happy Monday chicos! Looky the new ADF, exciting, yeah?!
So last discussion (Negative Feedback) camper SuperS wondered about feedback in general. Specifically review replies, here's a bit of what she had to say:
Is it just me, or do others feel really awkward when authors reply to a review? I mean any sort of review - good, bad, constructive, short. mini essay of all your thoughts etc etc - I just find it strange to have that further interaction. I get why some people love it, and authors taking pride in responding to reviews, but I have always just felt strange. Adds a pressure to me to keep reviewing (and I read a lot of WIPs, so then you feel like you can't flounce quietly or stop reviewing) and would set up expectations in my head about that author responding to my review.
I also feel that sometimes if I've written a quick review and then I get a reply, especially everytime, I feel like the effort from the author is undeserved - because I didn't do much....versus writing a really heartfelt long review and then getting nothing...and feeling let down?
As a result I rarely review anymore [. . .]
I found this INSANELY intriguing. And have to admit that I have wondered myself about my chatterbox nature, and inability to limit my wordiness (it's a character flaw, I try and work on it), because I engage my readers often with review replies. So I always wonder if they're reading my story for ME instead of the story.
So, what do you think?
How do you HONESTLY feel about review replies?
If you LOVE them, why? What has been your favorite review reply like? You're least favorite? Why?
If you HATE them, why? What about them sets you off? Is it that you personally don't like hearing from an author, or that you just think they shouldn't "waste" their time? Has it maybe set you off of the story because something was revealed in a reply?
If an author DOES review reply does your opinion of them change?
If an author DOESN'T review reply does it change your opinion about them?
What if an author had review replied once and doesn't again, how do you feel about that? Does it change anything?
Are there some reviews you WISH an author would respond to versus other ones you'd written? Why?
Do you think that some authors CAN actually add pressure to readers from review replying? Have you ever felt that way personally?
Writers how do YOU feel about review replying? What are your pros and cons for it? Is there a "right" way to reply and a wrong way?
Any GREAT experiences you want to share? Any bad ones?
Come chitter-chatter with me!