Last week, I finally finished all 1,022 pages of A Dance with Dragons. I had been waiting for this book to come out for over 5 years and had speculated on the content within since then.
Then the book came out.....
Back before Breaking Dawn came out, I used to love going to the message boards on Twilighted to speculate with my online friends about what that book would contain. We would talk about epic battles and vamp bella ad nausium and it was so much fun.
Then the book came out....
I remember back when Harry Potter was on book three. I would wait ever so patiently for even the littlest bit of information. When we would get glimpses of cover art online we would talk about it at detail. When we got chapter titles, the boards would explode. Would Harry end up with Hermione? Was Harry a Horcrux? The theories were astounding, fun and rampant.
Then the book came out.....
So my question is, can a book series ever live up to the speculation that surrounds it before it is written?
Can an author actually write as good of book as we can come up with as a group of followers? Is that a completely unfair thing to say and, in the age of fanfiction, should an author even care about what is speculated?
What is your favorite theory that was never realized in a fantasy/supernatural series? The one that you really wish would have happened?
Are our imaginations always better than the reality or does the final product ever exceed our expectations??