How do you feel about fandom content gone mainstream?
MOTU aka “Fifty Shades of Gray” topped the New York Times e-book bestseller list. As this article suggests, if the novel was only widely available in print, it would have topped in other rankings as well. To be honest, a few weeks back, when “Fifty” made it to one of the morning TV shows I thought “hey, perfect topic for breakfast TV watched by stay at home moms; no one really cares”. But now, after an article in the NY Times it seems that this novel is getting notice and “recognition” from BIG TIME media. And everyone is talking about it.
It really doesn’t matter how I feel about the fanfic-gone-novel and the questionable quality of the work, all of that has been discussed thousands of times. What really impresses me here is the how a piece of work, from a fandom where many of us treat fanfics like a secret guilty pleasure, is conquering the mainstream. It’s crazy don’t you think? I take interest in watching trends, but this one has blown my mind. There are of course elements of the sci-fi community that reach the mainstream, or small comic books picked up by TV networks. But those are few and far between and most of all, those works or ideas are usually so “digested” by the time they reach the general audience that they carry very little resemblance to their original form. With “Fifty” we have a niche genre (erotica), obscure themes (pseudo-BDSM) and the whole fanfiction stigma, yet somehow it’s a worldwide phenomenon, maybe even with a movie deal on the table.
Do you think E L James’ success will pave a way for more fanfic authors? How do you think this will affect the fandom? More P2P? Mass exodus? Or perhaps influx of more quality work?
Rec: Off the Record
"Friday, November fifteenth, 2024. Palo Alto, California. Interview with Edward Cullen, brother of missing New York Times journalist Emmett Cullen." When reporter Bella goes on assignment, what complications will arise? ExB, AH/AU.
Twilight - Rated: M - English - Drama/Romance - Chapters: 9 - Words: 46,018 - Reviews: 676 - Updated: 3-11-12 - Published: 1-2-12 - Bella & Edward