I did my monthly cleanup of stories on my alert list. Any story that hasn't been updated in 12 months, I remove from the list. If there is a story that was a good ways along and/or I was really interested in, I send the author a review asking about the status. This is typically what I send -
Just wondering if you plan on finishing this story or if I should take it off my watch list. If you do plan on finishing, do you have an idea of how many chapters are left? If not, can you give me a quick summary of the rest of the story so I know how it ends? Thanks!
Sometimes I get a response, sometimes not. Never have I gotten such a hostile response as the one I received today. This is what she responded with. (This first one wasn't bad. It's the second one that surprised me.)
I say take it off your list. I really don't have the time to finish at the moment, for matters that really are not anyones concern. And no I won't tell you how it ends. Sorry!
First, I didn't ask the "why"'s. Don't care. As she said, NOMB. But her saying that she wasn't going to finish and wouldn't give the ending made me sad. I read the first couple chapters and liked it and was waiting for it to finish to complete it. So I sent her this -
Well, thanks for letting me know you will not be continuing this story. The "why" doesn't matter to me. As you said, it's none of my concern, not that I was asking. (I don't really need/want to know the details) Altho, it kinda sucks that you won't give a hint as to how it would have ended. You put a lot of effort into this story and I'm thankful that you shared it with us readers. I was hoping to read it anyway because the summary was interesting and the first chapters caught my attention, but without any kind of ending, well, I just don't see the point. Ah well.
Oh! And FYI, when you disable your PM's, it makes it so people that you send a message to cannot read it. Luckily, I have it set up so it also sends a copy to my email, which is the only reason why I was able to read your response. :)
I thought it was fairly neutral. I wanted to be clear that I wasn't trying to pry into her private life or was trying to pressure her and that I enjoyed her writing. I know that some readers can get kind of aggressive and demanding to writers who haven't updated in a while, so I wanted to be clear that that was not my intention. I was just curious about the status.
I didn't realize her PM's were turned off until I tried to respond back and wasn't sure if she realized that I wouldn't be able to see her reply if they were so I thought I'd let her know just in case. It didn't make sense to me that she would reply knowing that I wouldn't see the actual message, ya know? Apparently she did not appreciate my efforts as this was her final reply -
I not once said that I wasn't going to finish the story. All I said was for you to take me off your alert. Cos I have no intention to share or continue the story for you. And for some reason it is only you that I feel strongly about not sharing how the story will end. I guess you caught me on a bad day.
Your bad.
As for disabling my PM don't feel special, I just don't have the energy to reply to the reviews and many requests I get everyday about my stories. Lets face it if I did then I would be writing.
Not quite sure what I did to offend her other than asking her the status of her story in a polite way, but if this is the way she treats all her readers (which, when you read the last paragraph where she basically states that she can't be bothered to even thank the readers for their support, it appears she does), well, it's probably a good thing she stopped writing.
To top it all off, she then blocked me from further reviewing her story. Kind of reminds me of when my 8 yr old throws his tantrums over some perceived wrongdoing. He'll go into the office and close the door and act like we don't exist. It frustrates him further when our only response is to giggle at him. LOL
Anyway, so, am I in the wrong? Was something I wrote offensive? As disappointed as I was, I tried not to be an ass towards her. I mean, it's just a story. It's nothing earth shattering. I was disappointed but not angry. I was only curious about the status. But if my initial inquiry is prickly, I'd like to know so that I can re-word it in the future.
My rec for this is a story that was abandoned for a while but recently started updating again.
Lessons in Forbidden Love by xsecretxkeeperx
We always want what we can't have but their love was so much more than just temptation. So what do you do when you fall in love with a student? That's the question Edward has to ask himself as he falls for his favorite student Bella. All Human,Not typical
Twilight - Rated: M - English - Romance/Hurt/Comfort - Chapters: 14 - Words: 81,213 - Reviews: 1667 - Updated: 3-28-12 - Published: 12-8-08 - Edward & Bella