As someone who actually liked BD, I am genuinely curious as to why people hate it so much.
Yeah, I know the fade to black sucked, but it is a YA book and SM is a Mormon, what did you expect?
Yeah, vamps and humans procreating is impossible, but were talking about a story where vamps and shapeshifters exist...it's a work of fiction, anything is possible.
Ok...I'll give you the whole birth of Reneesme. That was a bit graphic and gross. And I could've done without the chewing through the belly and breaking bones. BUT, I liked that they had a baby together even though her name sucks.
AND...the imprinting was a little weird.
But I am glad that there was an anti-climatic climax, I would have hated it if any of the Cullens were killed trying to fight the Volturi.
So tell what specifically did you hate about BD?
No smartass comments saying "Everything."
If you hated it, I really wanna know why and how you would have liked to see the saga end. Don't refer back to a fic, I want your take on it.