Okay, I've hardly ever started a campfire, but I've been thinking of this topic for quite a while and wondered about other readers' viewpoints.
Is fanfic a legitimate form of literature? As in, can it count as being "literary" in the traditional sense (copyright nonsense aside, we're talking quality)?
I read tons of fic, but I also read tons of books. I have always loved books, and I still love books...I just also love fic. The problem is that fic has become more interesting to me than books.
I just finished reading "Water for Elephants", both because it has a Twi connection (pathetic, I know), and because it's been in my pile for about two years and I happened to get to it. It was good. I liked the story, I liked the main character, but I found myself wishing that it had been written by one of maybe ten fic authors I know because they could do it better.
Is that just sad? I mean, WfE has won awards and is fairly well-written, but I have become super critical of any author now because I have seen so much excellent writing in the world of fic.
Spoilers for WfE if you don't want to know:
The relationship between Jacob and Marlena seemed rushed, forced, and lacking chemistry (it was all there, but their connection was not strong enough to merit Jacob's reactions, or rather it was not written in a strong enough way). There were pretty gross descriptions of the stripper and the dwarf's...assets...but they seemed just stuck there for shock value and not handled in a great way.
There are lots of other things I could comment on with WfE, and that is just one example of traditional fiction I've read lately that makes me pause and think of fanfic.
Am I crazy? I don't know, maybe. I wondered whether I only think that fic is more intriguing because Edward and Bella are always in them, but then I remembered that a really great story always makes me believe that the author could easily publish that story without E/B or any Twi mention and still have a great story that I would gladly read.
Is the definition of storytelling changing? Has the publishing industry, critics, and media's power to "decide" what people like buried the concept of placing good stories on shelves? Do we become addicted to fic because there are some really, really great stories out there amongst all that crap?
I don't know. You tell me.