The campfire from yesterday about sharing pulled fics got my wheels turning. Why is it so shunned upon for members of the fandom to share pulled fics, even those pulled for publishing? (And let it be known I’m not talking about STEALING someone’s fic where you try to pass it off as your own. I’m talking about sharing a fic with other people where the author was given proper credit.)
Serioulsy why? I.don’t.get.it. It’s not like we’re buying a story on Omnific then sharing that story with the world. The original story was all over the internet well before that! Plus it’s not like we’re making a profit off of sharing the pulled fics.
Yes, I’ve heard the argument about respecting the author’s wishes. If they chose to pull the story for whatever reason, we should do the honorable thing and respect that. But why? When putting your work on the internet, you take a risk of it being spread like wildfire. This has been happening for years with blog posts, news articles, cooking recipes, etc. Why is fan fiction above that?
Yes, an author can pull a fic, but that author also has no legal recourse should it get passed around. Because FFn stories are NOT protected under copyright laws. Period. This was reiterated to me in my copyright law class I just completed. If the author chose to put the story on a free site (Fan Fiction, ADF, Twilighted, Writer’s Coffeehouse, etc) in the public domain using borrowed characters, it’s not protected.
So why is it shunned upon for people to post links to download pulled fics (with the author given credit, of course)? And why do people who DO post links to downloaded fics get bullied until it’s removed?
Help me understand. Cause frankly I’m sick of the secrecy and the bullying. In my own opinion, I think it’s time that there was an open blog with links to pulled fics that everyone can use. We’re not making a profit. We’re not claiming it as our own. We’re READING it. And I will happily be the first one to start it.
Ok, hit me with the flames. I’ve got on my armor.
ETA: Ok, I am legit starting a blog (link to follow).
ETA: Campfire approved by grown.ass.woman!