So this came up as a side discussion in a thread several months ago, and I wanted to get far enough away from the thread that it wouldn't be in any way in response to the author of the original thread, becasue it's not mean t to be. (I don't even remember who started it, tbh.)
But there was a discussion about how people have different preferences in fic. And what hit me was that even though from my vantage point, all a preference is is a prefence, there's often a lot of baggage attached to it. For instnace, preferring vampfic means you're snooty, loving smut means you're shallow, liking a super-popular fic means you're just a sheep. We've all encountered those and similar judgments, or seen them attached to others. Because of that, I think sometimes folks can feel attacked for what they like, instead of having it feel no different than checking out at the bookstore with a romance vs. a contemporary mainstream novel vs. a fantasy novel.
So I'd like to do an experiment. Tell me, forest,
What Don't You Read?
I'm not talking about the "Oh, if it's exremely well-written, it doesn't matter." And I'd like to get away from the, "I love to read everything" kinds of conversations because the truth is, when you're stuck fic-diving, chances are there are things you go looking for over others to help you cull the pile. I think it goes without saying that the right fic can knock anyone off their feet and make them reconsider the things they enjoy in fanfic, and that most of us are open to reading anything if it comes strongly recommended, but I also think that most of us do have things that, if all else is equal, are going to make us choose to give our time to fic A over fic B. And that those differences should be discussed openly and celebrated without attaching extra meaning to them.
If this goes right, I hope it will be a showcase, almost like our Master Fic List, of how there's a lot of diversity in our fandom. So I'm thinking pairings, I'm thinking AH vs. vamp, I'm thinking historical vs. modern, I'm thinking romance vs. thriller, I'm thinking pack vs. Cullens, smut vs. UST, take your pick.
What do you disprefer to read? What floats your boat? What's going to be the deciding factor between Fic A and Fic B if they're both kind of okay? And even more interesting, when do you reach for a fic that is kind of okay because it has the features you want, instead of the fic that is amazingly well done but just not really up your alley? And what, if you had your way, would you like to see more of in fandom? Order it up. And lets just see how different our orders are.
And if you've got some thoughts on why preferences have turned into judgments, I'd love to hear those, too.