So, I just read that Michelle Trachtenburg was actually in the running to be Bella Swan. :O
Maybe I'm just late to the party, but I never knew that! And now that I do, I can't help but wish she would have been cast. The girl can act like a shy teenager with way more skill that KStew (though stuttering, breathing a lot, and vigorous shaking of the head were just bril. *sarcasm, sarcasm*) and I personally feel she looked more like my Bella (rounder face, bigger eyes, right hair color, huge lips) than Kristen.
Now, that being said, Rob is definitely my Edward. Not when the movies first started, but I never had a solid choice anyways, so it was easier for me to let him slip into that position, and I think he did a good job with it; particularly in the last three movies. I wouldn't want him replaced, which makes me wonder if I want Stewart replaced. Because despite Kristen's less than stellar acting abilities, she had chemistry with Rob. Would my perfect Bella, Michelle, have that same chemistry? Maybe, maybe not.
Ashley was not my Alice, (she looked WAY too old with that wig) Nikki was not my Rosalie, (again with the wig. And she just looked like a brunette. Does that make sense? She didn't have the beauty of a blonde. Not that she wasn't beautiful, or that brunettes are less pretty!! I just mean that she looked like a brown headed girl. Even her features looked better suited for a long, flowing, BROWN head o' hair) And Taylor was not my Jacob. (His voice is just so... I don't even know.)
So, who would you put in these roles? Who is your dream cast for Twilight? Would you pick Rob? Would Michelle have done a better job being Bella? Lemme know!
I'm sure there have been a hundred campfires about this.. Sorry!! :)