Readers and writers – what are your opinions regarding reviews on the various sites you read/post a story?
I had a fascinating PM exchange with a reader a few months ago, who expressed surprise when I replied to her review, thanking her for taking the time to share her thoughts with me. This reader told me that she's been in the fandom a few years now, and has noticed that fewer authors are sending out review replies, and how that's affecting her willingness to read or review any of their future stories, should they post more. She thanked me for my response, and that conversation inspired me to really consider her point of view, one that appreciates the personalized expression of gratitude in a private reply, a reciprocation of acknowledgment from one person to another.
Personally, I don't care how busy I am, I will stay up a little later at night or make every effort to respond to every review I get (it may take me a week or two, but I will), because I believe that in all facets of life, a compliment/comment deserves a response, and a kind one, if possible, based on the approach that positivity breeds more positivity, paying it forward and subconsciously inviting more of it, etc.
In my opinion, It's encouraging to hear from a reader, and I feel that by responding, it's an extension of the process we engage in when we write or read fanfiction. Granted, there is a difference between “expecting” things and hoping for them, and there's a fine line we balance when we post a story or review.
I don't believe a writer is obligated to post a new chapter any more than a reader is obligated to review it.
But isn't it nice when both things happen?
Yet we are all so busy with our lives, and may not have the chance to respond to every comment, etc. It's not physically possible for some to do it all – write, read, post on our favorite net places, review, review reply...all the while having to manage our personal lives/careers/etc. And what I find important may not be a shared opinion of others – but it does get me thinking about what fanfiction and reviews are about. It's about exchange/interaction to some, and a hands-off kind of hobby to others, both readers and writers alike. Yet it's rarely discussed, and hearing from that reader again this morning reminded me about how many opinions there must be out there, regarding this issue of reviews.
Readers:
What are your opinions about leaving a review, or receiving a response from the author? Do you have any expectations when you begin reading and/or reviewing a story? Does it upset you to see an author ask for reviews, or holding their future chapters hostage until they reach a certain number? Are you surprised when you receive a thank you for your review, or is a response a standard occurrence for you?
Authors:
What are your opinions about the review process? Do the one word reviews or “smiley faces only” bother you (I've heard that criticism a lot from authors, over the years)? Do you try to respond to reviews individually or do you prefer to leave a “thank you” in your authors notes, freeing up more time to write in your already hectic day? Do you feel that reviews are helpful or a hindrance to your creative process?
I look forward to reading your opinions, and wish you all a wonderful day!
Becca
______________________________________________________________
And to feed a tree, a story update I run to when I see it come into my in-box:
Quarterback Sneak by jayhawkbb
As a Seattle sports talk radio host, it's my job to give my opinion on the Seahawks new quarterback, Edward Cullen. But maybe I shouldn't have said what I did...you know, about his butt. E/B Rated M for language and adult content.
Rated: Fiction M - English - Romance/Humor - Chapters: 9 - Words: 66,836 - Reviews: 1,707 - Favs: 1,590 - Follows: 2,550 - Updated: 03-17-13 - Published: 08-31-12 - id: 8483034