I've been emotionally stressed out lately, and it has given me moments of compulsion to write, and moments of jello-brain in which I can barely have a conversation with anyone else. So, I've been reading bits and bobs from the Eddies and Bellies list that I'd never been up-to-speed on, and I found a recurring trend in All-Human stories.
I have no idea who these characters are. They aren't Edward and Bella. They're called Edward and Bella, but they have cutthroat competitions over inconsequential conflict, or one of them is somewhat cruel, or they recite entire poems, songs, or movies to each other, or ...or something else. I can't keep up.
And these poems or songs or brands of tea they choose: Some of the references in stories nowadays (see how I date myself?) are things entirely outside my realm.
I'm completely out of touch, and the stories go over my head, and then I think to myself: Well, Hell. I've got plenty of tidbits in every story I've written that can come off as pretentious or outlandish or bizarre or ridiculously off-base. And then I iget paranoid about alienating people the way I feel alienated by these stories.
And so I've formulated a theory that is exactly why we find ourselves in the situation we're in now... as a "community" as a "fandom"... Whatever you choose to call this rag-tag intercontinental herd of DARING, INTELLIGENT WRITERS who've demonstrated exceptional bravery in exploring their passions by writing and then DISPLAYING their produce publicly for all to see and dissect... Whatever you name us, we have recently come to a crossroads where we snipe and pick as much as we support. Sometimes the scales balance too far in the negative, and I really do feel a cold twist below my chest when I see slights. But I acknowledge them.
Plenty of times I’ve heard that no other fandom has the flounce-pull-and-publish issue like the Twilight fandom does.
Do you think it's because twific isn't based at all on Twilight anymore? Do you think we’re TOO out of the realm of twilight and THAT’S where our issues are stemming from?
If we’d never so vastly veered from canon, would we be where we are now with all of the fuckery and flouncing and hissing?
I'm going to advocate vampire fluff from now on. Canon all the way.
tl;dr: have AH fics made us all into bloodsuckers?
smoke and mirrors: